Loving-Kindness Meditation: A Guide to Self-Compassion

Loving-kindness meditation asks you to do one thing: wish someone well, on purpose, in the same words, over and over.

No analysis. No insight. No working out why you feel the way you feel. You pick a person, you say four short phrases in your head, and then you pick another person and say them again. Described that way it sounds like almost nothing, which is the first obstacle most people run into.

The practice is old. It comes from the Buddhist tradition, where it is called metta bhavana, and it has been in use for roughly two and a half thousand years. It arrived in DBT and in other modern treatments for an unsentimental reason. It produces measurable change, and it produces it in people who do not believe in it while they are doing it.

‍

‍

What the practice actually is

Most meditation you have heard of works by narrowing attention. You watch the breath, or you watch whatever arrives and note it. Loving-kindness does something different. It generates a state rather than observing one. You are deliberately producing goodwill, the way you might deliberately produce a scale on a piano.

The structure is a sequence. You start with yourself, move to someone you already care about, then to someone you barely know, then, if you want to, to someone you find difficult, and finally outward to everyone. At each step you repeat the same phrases.

What separates this from positive thinking is the absence of a transaction. You are not trying to get anyone to like you, and you are not trying to talk yourself into feeling better. The wish is offered whether or not it is received, whether or not it is deserved, whether or not you feel anything while you make it. That unconditional quality is the part that does the work, and it is also the part people skip.

‍

What the research shows

The evidence base is larger than people expect for something this simple. Regular practice is associated with more frequent positive emotion, lower scores on measures of depression and anxiety, and a marked reduction in self-criticism. Imaging work shows more activity in regions tied to empathy and emotional processing, and less in the network associated with self-focused rumination.

One often cited study found that seven minutes of directing loving-kindness toward a stranger increased reported feelings of connection and positivity toward that person. Other work has found improvements in vagal tone, which is one of the better physiological markers of how efficiently a person recovers from stress.

The finding that matters most clinically is narrower. For people who are hard on themselves, or who feel cut off from other people, this practice reliably softens both. Not quickly, and not permanently, but enough that the internal voice changes register.

‍

The practice, step by step

Sit somewhere you can be alert without being uncomfortable. Eyes closed or gaze lowered. Take a few breaths before you start, not to relax but to stop moving.

Start with yourself. For many people this is the hardest step, and it is worth knowing that in advance. Bring yourself to mind, or simply notice yourself sitting here. Then say the phrases, silently or under your breath:

May I be safe and protected from harm.
May I be healthy and strong.
May I be happy and peaceful.
May I live with ease.

Say them slowly. Do not chase a feeling. You are putting something in the ground, and nothing in the instructions says it has to sprout today.

Move to someone who has been good to you. A friend, a teacher, a grandparent, a dog. Someone whose kindness toward you is not in question. Hold them in mind and send the same four lines:

May you be safe and protected from harm.
May you be healthy and strong.
May you be happy and peaceful.
May you live with ease.

Then someone neutral. The person at the counter, a neighbour you nod to, whoever was two seats down on the train. This step looks like filler and is not. It is where the practice stops being about your relationships and starts being about the plain fact that a stranger wants the same four things you do.

May you be safe and protected from harm.
May you be healthy and strong.
May you be happy and peaceful.
May you live with ease.

Then, if you want to, someone difficult. Start with mildly irritating rather than genuinely harmful. The point is not to decide that what they did was acceptable. The point is that holding a person in permanent ill will costs you something, and this is one way of putting the cost down. If it is not available today, skip it. Skipping it is a normal part of the practice, not a failure of nerve.

May you be safe and protected from harm.
May you be healthy and strong.
May you be happy and peaceful.
May you live with ease.

Then everyone. Widen it out until it has no edges.

May all beings be safe and protected from harm.
May all beings be healthy and strong.
May all beings be happy and peaceful.
May all beings live with ease.

Sit for a moment afterward with whatever is there, including nothing. Then open your eyes.

‍

Changing the phrases

The traditional four are well made, but they do not fit every mouth. What matters is that the words are yours, and that saying them does not feel like reciting a form.

Shorter:

• May I be happy.
• May I be healthy.
• May I be safe.
• May I be at peace.

Plainer:

• May you be free from suffering.
• May you feel loved and accepted.
• May you have what you need.
• May you know your own worth.
• May you be free from fear.

Aimed at what is actually going on this month:

• May you find rest when you are exhausted.
• May you be gentle with yourself.
• May you heal from this.
• May you find courage in the difficult part.

Some people work with one line and repeat it like a metronome. Others rotate. The test is simple. Does saying it open something, or does it sound like a form letter. If it is the second, change the words.

‍

When the practice brings something difficult

Resistance, sadness, anger and boredom all show up in this practice. None of them mean you are doing it wrong. Usually they mean you have touched something that was already there.

If aiming kindness at yourself is unbearable or brings grief, that tells you how long you have gone without it. Crying during this practice is common. You can also take the back route. Bring to mind someone who loves you, imagine them saying the phrases to you, and stay there for a few weeks before you try saying them to yourself directly.

If you feel nothing and the words sound hollow, continue anyway. This is the part people misunderstand. The practice works through repetition, not through sincerity of feeling in the moment. You are creating the conditions for warmth, the way watering creates the conditions for a plant. You are not the one doing the growing.

If a difficult person produces only anger, leave them out. Most teachers would rather you built a foundation first. If you want a middle position, wish that they find peace in a way that does not cost anyone else.

If the commentary starts, and it will, some version of this is stupid or I am not doing this right or nothing is happening, notice it and let it stand. You can even fold it in. May this critical part of me be at ease.

‍

Variations

With the body. Put a hand on your chest while you say the phrases, or picture warmth spreading through you or through the person you are holding in mind. Words plus sensation tends to land harder than words alone.

Toward parts of yourself. Aim the phrases at the specific things you usually judge. The anxious part. The ageing body. The version of you who was twelve. May this anxious part of me find peace.

Out in the day. Offer a silent line to people you pass. The parent losing it in the supermarket. The driver who cut across you. The colleague who has clearly not slept. This turns dead time into practice time and it costs nothing.

After gratitude. Start by bringing to mind something you are actually glad about, let that warm up, then run the phrases from there. Easier ignition on a cold day.

On the breath. In, receive kindness for yourself. Out, send it outward. The rhythm does some of the work for you.

Just today. If the full phrases feel too large, shrink the timeframe. May I be at peace today. May I find one good moment today. May I be kind to myself today.

‍

Carrying it into the day

Formal practice is where the skill is built. The change shows up somewhere else.

When you catch yourself in self-criticism, stop and offer one line. May I be kind to myself right now. It interrupts the run, which is usually all that is needed.

When you feel cut off from people, remember that everyone in the room wants the same four things. Wish it for them silently. The sense of being the odd one out tends to loosen.

When someone has annoyed you, take one breath before responding and think, may you be at peace. This is not agreement and it is not permission. It changes the state you answer from.

At night, run the sequence in bed. Yourself, the people you love, everyone. It is a better last thought than the one you would otherwise have.

When you hear about something terrible in the world, and the choice is between turning away and drowning, there is a third option. Offer the phrases. It is small, and small is not the same as nothing, and it keeps you from closing.

‍

What the practice is not

Loving-kindness is not a method for feeling better, although feeling better often follows. It is training in a particular quality of care: unconditional, unattached to the result, offered whether or not anything comes back.

Which means you can practice it on a terrible day. You can practice it toward someone who will never change. You can practice it while feeling nothing warm at all. The practice is the point, and the outcome is a side effect.

The side effects are still worth naming. People report feeling less separate, judging faster and holding it more lightly, forgiving themselves more quickly after a mistake. Arguments hook them less. They find they have more goodwill available than they thought, which is usually a surprise.

‍

When it feels impossible

For people with a history of trauma, neglect or abuse, this practice can be destabilising, particularly when it is aimed at yourself or at someone who caused harm. That is information about where to start, not evidence of a defect.

Modifications that help:

• Begin with a pet or a child you love, where the feeling moves without effort
• Use safer phrases. May I be safe lands differently from may I be loved
• Work alongside a therapist or a teacher who understands trauma
• Keep it very short at first. Thirty seconds is a real practice
• Stay with neutral people or with all beings until self directed kindness is available
• Stop whenever you need to. Returning to the breath is always allowed

Nothing here requires you to love everyone, or to love yourself today. It is an invitation with no penalty attached for declining part of it.

‍

Try this: seven minutes, one stranger

Pick someone you saw today and do not know. The person ahead of you in the queue, the one who held a door, whoever was behind the counter. You do not need their name and you will probably never see them again.

Set a timer for seven minutes. Hold them in mind and run the four phrases, slowly, for the whole seven minutes. When your attention wanders, and it will, go back to the phrases. Do not switch to anyone easier.

Seven minutes is the interval used in the study mentioned above, and it is short enough that you will actually finish. What most people notice afterward is not a feeling about that stranger. It is that the next person they deal with gets a slightly better version of them, for about an hour.

‍

Where to go next

For the same warmth turned toward yourself in a shorter practice, see affectionate breathing. For the attention skills this sits on top of, start with the DBT What skills, and for working with feelings as they arrive, mindfulness of current emotions. The version aimed at other people in conversation is validation as a way to connect.

Dr. Jesse Finkelstein works with self-compassion in individual therapy at Axis Psychological Services in New York City. You can book a free consultation.

If you want to build a steady practice with support, learn about DBT therapy in NYC, or join the DBT skills group in NYC.